Spotify’s biggest playlists are losing followers, and Benji Stein says that’s mostly good news for independent artists. Stein is the founder of Innovation Syndicate, the company behind the curator search engine PlaylistSupply. His team has just published the 2026 Playlist & Music Marketing Report, a report on playlist data showing that independent curators, not editorial lists, drive discovery for nearly every artist under a million monthly listeners.
We spoke with Benji about what the cleanup means for artists, how to spot pay-for-play playlists, and how to pitch curators who never asked for your music.
What problem in playlist marketing made you build the PlaylistSupply tool, and how has the platform changed as Spotify has changed?
I built PlaylistSupply because finding real Spotify playlist curators was slow, manual work, and the contact lists people sold were outdated or full of botted playlists. I was managing artists at the time and my co-founder was a booking agent, so we were building for problems we had experienced ourselves in the industry.
So we made a search engine that looks things up live. You type in a genre or an artist and get playlists and curator contacts back.
As Spotify changed, the tool changed with it. Follower counts stopped meaning much, so we built Similar Artist search, which shows the playlists that are actually getting artists like you discovered. Then came PlaylistVet, to check a playlist is alive before you pitch. Now Connect AI lets you do all of it from ChatGPT or Claude.
My tip: start your search with three artists who sound like you, not with a genre keyword.
Spotify's crackdown is shrinking the biggest playlists. Good news, bad news, or both?
Both, but mostly good news. The biggest Spotify playlists are losing followers, most likely because fake accounts are being cleared out, and that makes room for the playlists real fans actually chose.
In our report, RapCaviar peaked at 16.16 million followers in April 2025 and has slipped about 2.6% since. The four most-followed playlists on Spotify are all losing followers. Over the same year, the independent playlists we tracked grew a median of 10%, against 1% for the Spotify-owned ones.
The bad news is for anyone leaning on inflated numbers. A big follower count is not proof of reach anymore, and Spotify has been pulling back plays it counts as artificial.
My tip: stop sorting playlists by size. Before you pitch, check whether a playlist is actually sending listeners to artists. That's what PlaylistVet is for.
Independent vs editorial playlists: should artists change where they focus?
Yes. If you have under a million monthly listeners, independent Spotify playlists are where discovery happens, so that's where most of your playlist pitching time should go.
Our report looked at the playlists Spotify itself credits with discovering artists. For every artist under a million monthly listeners, independent playlists made up 80 to 92% of them. Editorial was about 1% at the bottom of the market and only reached about 27% for the largest artists. By the time editorial shows up, you're already big.
I'd still submit every release to Spotify's editors. It's free and takes a few minutes. Just don't make it the plan.
My tip on how to get on Spotify playlists: put an artist who sounds like you into PlaylistSupply's Similar Artist search. It shows the playlists already getting artists like you discovered, with curator contacts where we can find them.
Pay-for-play warning signs, and how you define it
A pay-for-play playlist is any playlist that charges you for a spot. My position is simple: never pay for placement, and vet every playlist before you pitch it.
In the research we can't see money change hands, so we look for the signs of selling, mainly a "submit your track to this email" line in the bio. We re-checked about 825,000 active playlists and roughly 1.9% were gone. The deleted ones were 3.5 times more likely to show a contact email and 2.2 times more likely to list an Instagram promo handle.
A contact email alone doesn't make a curator shady. The pattern does: a throwaway account, a pile of genre-titled playlists, and a submission line in the bio.
My tip: run the playlist through PlaylistVet or BotCheck first. If it isn't driving real listening, move on.
How to approach a curator who isn't asking for music; good pitch vs bad pitch
Treat it like introducing yourself to a person, not filling out a form. Most Spotify playlist curators who drive discovery never asked for music, so a short, personal note stands out.
In our report, 93% of the playlists that drive discovery had no submission pitch at all, and about one in eleven had any contact route. When there is one, it's more often a social profile than an email. That's why PlaylistSupply looks up curator contacts for you, both email and Instagram.
A good pitch is three or four sentences. Say why your song fits their playlist, name a track on it that sits next to yours, and send one link. A bad pitch is a copy-paste blast with your whole bio and five links.
My tip: listen to the playlist before you write. Follow up once, then let it go.
Where playlist marketing goes in 2027
Playlist marketing in 2027 will be less about landing on one giant playlist and more about real listeners on smaller ones. Spotify's big playlists get more personalized every year, so two people can open the same playlist and hear different songs.
There's also more noise. Spotify says it removed over 75 million spam tracks in a single year, and I expect the cleanup to keep going. Curators with real audiences get more valuable when that happens.
AI tools will take over the research. With Connect AI, you can ask ChatGPT or Claude to find playlists in your genre and get curator contacts and a health score from PlaylistSupply. The pitch still has to come from you.
My tip: start now. Build a list of 20 to 30 vetted independent playlists that fit your sound, and get to know the curators before your next release.
